We love these personal-size pies! The crust is really good and tastes so much like that of a homemade pie. The filling is substantial and also tastes like if I had made it myself. All the flavors we have tried are delicious and excellent quality.
I have to say I was disappointed overall with the pies. The cherry and blueberry just didn't have enough filling. I consider myself a pie expert that is why I ordered them to try. The best pies are light crust, not over-doughy and full of fruit filling. The cherry pie was very thin on cherries, it really ended up being more like a cherry turnover you can buy at the store. Although the little cherry filling that was there did taste good. The blueberry was the same way, just not enough rich blueberry filling. The only pie that seemed to have anywhere close to a decent amount of filling was the apple. I won't be ordering again, overall very disappointed in the filling content in the cherry and blueberry. I could tell you guys were skimping on that cost. You have a great concept for sure, but I didn't pay $60 to get a lot of dough and light filling. My overall take is that you guys skimped big time on the more expensive filling products of cherry and blueberry and that was enough to turn me off. I was really hoping that wasn't going to be the case. Good luck to you guys though.
We are so surprised to hear that this was your experience with Mamie's Pies!
We charge a higher price point because we use only high quality products and we absolutely do not skimp on filling!
The only explanation for this must be human error in our production line. We rarely hear complaints about a lack of filling, so to see you had that experience with two of our flavors isn't normal! We would like to make this right and offer you a new 12-pack :)
Why as my order shipped incomplete and no one is replying to my inquires to get this settled.
Thank you so much for reaching out. You replacement shipment will be on it's way to you next week! :)
America The Beautiful | Variety 12 Pack
I know you have delivered order 5229 that went to Az. But that was just one address of 3 that was in that order. Order 5226 was a multiple order that had 3 deliveries in it which was 5227,5228, and 5229. 5229 was delivered. I have still not been informed that 5227 and 5228 has been shipped. And I am still waiting for order # 5152 to be shipped and I ordered that one on December 14th. The pies taste great but your delivery service leaves a lot to be desired I’m sorry to say. What I don’t understand is how one order with in a multiple order can be delivered and the other 2 on the same order has not been delivered. Please get my orders shipped